There are some unislamic customs which have crept into our eid day celebrations nowadays. We must be on guard against them so they do not spoil the reward we hope to obtain on this occasion. For example:
1. Eid cards. The custom of sending eid cards is not prevalent in our society.
There are many sinful things that go along with sending eid cards, and a few are highlighted below:
A. many cards have pictures living things like animals and it is forbidden to snap animate beings, draw them, see them, like them and send them to each other.
B. some also carry nude or semi-naked pictures of women. It is a sin to see them, draw them, or make them and print them.
C. people compete with each other in sending a greeting card better than the other’s. They vie with each other in this way to be spoken of and this conduct is nothing but ostentation. Competition in sinful activities makes the sin graver.
D. if someone sends cheap eid cards then he is looked down upon and subject to taunts. Taunting anyone in itself is a sin and to compel or incite him to do a sinful thing is a more grave sin.
2. Some people convey their greetings by telephone or telegram, email, sms,etc. this has nothing to do with religion but is mere custom. No one should think that this is a sunnat or a part of the deen.
3. Many people embrace each other after the Eid salaat and think that it is sunnat or wajib to do so. This is incorrect, instead of it being a sunnat, it is in fact a bidat that must be avoided.
The fatwa of Mufti Muhammad Shafi (ra) the late mufti azam of Pakistan is:
To shake hands and embrace one another on eid day is a bidah and a symbol of the rawafid (shia). It must be given up.
The fatwa of Mufti Muhammad Taqi Uthmani:
Handshake at the time of meeting of two Muslims is masnoon. Also, to embrace one who returns from a journey is sunnah apart from these two occasions it is not sunnat. However, if anyone does not regard it as sunnat but does so incidentally then it is not a sin. If he considers it a sunnat and does it then it is a bidat. Since in our times the handshake after fard salaat and embrace after eid salah are considered as sunnat though they are not known from the Prophet (sallallahu alaihi wasallam) or the sahabah, so the ulema have declared them as bidat and urged that they should be shunned.
4. Mubarak (Congratulations)
There are several opinions on whether it is permissible to greet one another with the words “Eid Mubarak” or other expressions like this on the day of eid. Some say it is allowed because it is a dua and a good expression.
Some say it is makrooh because it is a Jewish practice.
Some say it is advisable because it is dua and it is mustahab to make dua for your brother.
Some say one should not greet but if someone else greets first he should repeat what the first person said.
In short, greetings on Eid are not known from any hadith and opinions differ about it from early times. Ulema proclaim it to be mubah (permissible) provided it is not accompanied by any factor which transforms it into Makrooh and Bid’ah. In our day, this expression is bid’ah because it has developed into a grounded custom. People believe that it is among the Mustahabbat of Eid. The younger generation grows up with this custom.
But if it is free from all disallowed things then it will be allowed. The disallowed things being: to consider it as sunnat, to regard it as necessary like fard or wajib, to treat it as fard or wajib, not to condemn one who did not practice it, to say it not before but after the masnoon salaam on meeting and then say eid mubarak or similar words.
Only when all of these factors are in place can it be said that giving eid greetings are permissible.